Charmides,_or_TemperanceNMNMBOOKMOBI]/%+N3<0E! N V_hpyiM "$&(*w,.402468 : <>@!B'D-F5mH=JC~LKUNNPNROTPVQXQ9ZQe\g'MOBI鑯)( /P+-,)EXTH-e*The University of Adelaide LibrarymCharmideseBooks@Adela ra( 2006mbp:pagebreakp647771}566Thisebdipublish6;aref="http://ebQ.aT.edu.au/blueuGEuRenderoTML߈߈߈wwwLjdirectory/stephen.thomas'''Steveԁoo??ooooooLastpdSunug 29 18:20:431077oooooooorksisuyÚptiCommonś<(availablet/cc.org/s/by-nc-sa/2.5/u>߂߂߂߂u/__k).oure:opy,istributebplaanderformhemakeerivsDifollowingnCs:muxat֝Xbmann specifisor;+ayosXxmmercialrpo;fal0,9,ruilpHV,.ׄ2resultonlydpic@one.ƃ`anyhވيcleaHorsermf.Ȁeba p;getmissfro :rair BAsxnoyff(WaboveOOOOOoolgGGGTUnrsit2braryǂDžgSouthȉa 5005wNmbp:pagebkG3em???"4xb000ހ\džZǁ>ABLEFCǁǁǃǁONTENTSߕ'!leftaile=4084' P(acȠyir8e@o611465s0Jhird]sgggggggggga58381g`Introduc焇73247ChaHdesbTemanc ߄߄߄ߝ/>PN Lj®}<ƃH2m̀Ƀ/Tp0Oaedr

Ian1aȏMr.rotBadmits uallcommonlyttriPla01ntiquity ythSchaarschm臊somrnjHcYcsoject8arhalfST,QmɁfcechiefonoГrnhee;ppq0ltopuxxqPvarietdoctyl҉c6dqaact,8enDialoguesXgardS N.ȁPhaedru0SymposiumqpdLaw:ork`ifP(醲m薚beЂapɍ\؊0aonqQiculSaol! (ntiirg"duc?HoolIbasp

B0i8CollegJanuary, 1871OHmbp:pbk/>InshaecopE(5)Dialoguإ-iEng*aacknowled(sPȭfrds:Rev.GradleMasP Unrsity߃ eWminysente somealuableemarksnhehaedo;fr.reenhill,hoadgainviseporti TimaeusMR.L.ettleship,ellowndutorIBalliolollege,omasndebtpfxanxc(entriticismParmenide,boveRev.rofessCampbxSt.ndrewsЅav(ni,ate0ud遈Christ8urchithIre(rgxt`parҀtrans.\also8EvelynbbottwwvZompleiaccur x.

Ii hirddon,amreryCbs-MatwnIsoxnlyavourb&suggerhroughoutrwork,palargXteIq (fr61y175@)=EryxiYSeco8AlcibiaƁkƌcher?

monizX̒8liclragfCxm‘!hh>ӂwూram_Y`w`0ibȠZCmean9wek;9n)uroka蠩8polWu8itutXфis{gɥzad@쑀z(H!Yϥʋytimesow(a8inuxm ؃.ƒy0tb YPrd j׮$Ohoqu1capa)М0.ȅؖ`q lf-trolled;9B[(ruw.eim؉Cat|avouچ'aPnorocaطxp(xberudgink0jnaYkeep!,O1AkаeyupFcop±iginaldowgav(Rep.)y@4hebhpu+cholars;imexc ,ЃQPg*lanyث͛񟈪HhipѢgrehujp@jdexxbperhaps0YɁpu ilefstm (Siroshuaeynolds(ces:isc.vP f"q'(f\rL dѝшJ m`. (1pstruYs@rtdsalnӁDintial;yem`e pةr‘wmeaeвPdi3r0a`s,w8ehnciPD!hz*ЁxQțHԉ;aİ`̭;fdmon&srubb@of'#glm:yfe khnҲ҅1l t` ȶ pla8sPA,ZЛre2xPgaj rǃxtؑ9erkaincreasedyheantfdversativendnferentialarticlesnglish,2,niceenseYtautologyhichharacterizallodernanguages.eannotatwo ‘buts’rforHsamtenwhGreekepeats (z).ԁ i(imilar'expressingZvariousradonsyobjecnsu~thought`Qlike,a@soicklycated8ge.urr:nrealoxymperfHegBcommonistin `betweenŎ[dbin2Jsug(Hubtlhadbneg{\#be5.HPimohd`ndPupЄ1apposiclausYُs,edifficultnؒ m:`truowcaؕ F9s냀equeہorwPrWHemphasrz.

(2)iZeဤaph ؊١pցr.linÂ8ydividagenerxyu :mark'#Àanci0.oth"^xq@ci@definitedoruonQerRalhrregu)eveloppfromn6yтtepgumqQarrۀzstate;q O@s0nitu8Zt@newi(sp) aPla`0alwaysertaSPMbegiЃəs;wwffl$AriȐ3;Ry[0XIݔYisobePepSoX 肀@@c wrbHpoet0prose@kWbaȈH7]hrodfuitab88erv stZ0l+(*yϙoѬedcxauJLad9,a`؄avoid瞨( XrmepHrar7777777331ihowpH!1di8ransar;+s裂HtȟA((怙رM wRshxemn 5simisexݲo8nim;ullsȎboutwarⴋbd0Hrl Ә˝)H80hBfh$pћaFÐ9cYވn(@aku\{virtu0maPur3ahqȉɵqdesc{0hisuoussuppH"ai’rpdoubtfuhsoni@Bchur!couȔ`Nowiuμyɷ2iraco73, s%mythgom0k4_ԺtF*wes,cc)irXxkenghn ;fHiImb§R!Q7,anatooQtcYЇ{ 1oIfixed8| napxsЈM<ɟbPtl"ߟ̄Ѣ*|Nchᣠrin ph0ehstyleaaפ:+«儻canyaltogy ShѥoYiquaf,w9wisdo0ulikٝӈ(?"us9do@dm0

(4)o`reismorXxdedthan.artlgrarietygrsRcasesak0yconnex\QacedЈ:{als{numb8Pdemonsp~pro,rticle, r(ideaspl"natural.ԁppȇ0o3hair1el1ao"oicdwhichra`ouXmonAHs;B8arՄdowlevelK,XeakpS wo2shor.eiHCsamecisQrequirxL,pilixoner;wnoth9@ck (tempoؔThucydXPanauEInu eniĞlanguag1aat\ulH}ibl@^wxYrdinpЂtweWa@aBfeltІ!asp91nper,nfaisAdiom,ㅀ͠.ƈYСt=plad.This atz81mselqwiqaoughrafRaoXAF0viYHhieeW0oppo!utpgy,4UadifficulXvo ///////*5(no4ucؔ(laidabo?ͺ;sePai8mpenIaOatrL9wiva? ssw8anyewpʤ9ݗAevaBY%kiKbtua4meaniz󂢭R˒Иal؅gg.ejkl(tڌpqуc(mrom¢)Нdj,<9iciP2erbilimed un8as1.ҵKons0arjohnғϐ̦pc -HagrapK0j,9ነflccurH Á8tp`some.trica,xcepwe𧐄,eZetc.phфćo.ž;) ;JhښliXalCa}9(uꚯ cꩿ򎲇tcoȞ(wA¢sph*anci¤0DžޅClimdow0xsALonnexh, a並/nc( aْirmiɊpicX0s1Ajaʐxd`{ߩxa@ 2iemxqn푉waytIfurn8⋕Az PzSeOi 򣓣92hkҘfȪ: yexha(6cEar@t,m(XDfaxHr na;posځRyqڂ(&8Nlo Qsty8whoh.Ŷbtt8battainCBxclu4familiarnddiomaticords.utreatareusteaken;ohrase,fexceptionoheeneraltyl1sftselisturbinglement.oR,oweverpressiveexact,houldemployewhichPs0dstopink,rndulyttrhsIbyfficultpe`pityⅤeffectqsurrolanguage.n6*Qonuthnotppropriatoor;snocie)soylers8x0txyha‘aoodohwn,’pdmo "agl. (a)rchaon heavoided.quival(syoccaalPdrawnromhaksp@PKcommerЄull;hȕ\usedpngly.or,ikomȅ1en)iH ElizabethJacobeigxdidapabilitip,HJJW

(7swodHcW(IXuleفxct8Xakytt(xt\aalwayR-ak§ ɟ„XswhiNewԅ(@uب@phteɚbՁc`n@ßcݖ 3ςtim*$pccup2varyqi!or؂ѡTsc@ceknow`[aGcl'͆pi!pohchRd:s.ɒ蝍AchogenJ,i•pfaulH1a`fiЂlrE\-2fspe///////+8kIlHVp@Dialogue;PHCviadapJtiditbruptᄁquJnsw|Itp"CrovodLi emicitrIbp(l ЂѤfroducaon,pfls.r!u4Irogvaiрemorɂ`re0itselpithtereadinessoheialogueorm.ostfso-callednglishālsreutoormitationsPlato,hicheryPrhororiginal.Ԁpbreathcons,Kubtledjustmenq8nd swerslivelylayAfancypo(drawingharactp,wantinxBцnici Amase8@ ,A#SocraticraligurH !l0per؃:—insolencfrasymachu(ang3CicAnytpatrxzastyrotagoxelf-hsciousn3dicuHippiɏQpa0ertain(oeputh`Hjmagameftrequir8HrppoetryluXoȂ0a0nxquality;B roseցpslowdtEiasCea72lȁKajti)

II.ɘ80xӉDhaveedd so`ayPnodernhiophP!pocȑfeschiefjsss(Uti,ommunismKIa+Hegeli.iePsychgOLl. (pGFalcir(dremarko!..ma8xdSgpЁ;Preface.)Anci8ύ̃rapny2:zPy1uldco,oanfounPlt0gÀnexbetw!񝢒p!ccidalؘ:oftPbrffhޣcliz;xc aBwohsurvhhA8da H-ic$rrHotmeana13famȼx[SRno PgЎ8gЏplᗡwɱ9yeaXYenlНAckqعedrsng.e Ь2#r҅wdwaylaimyinit!sm^[YzpiGreekψˋihowe)9ubinLJ,Zaewxx,ґriaXemiDXe;apimulfropudy:wCxr!fcȕ;Hseemshth萰$hfirSseaد́k`ertˈeespalUۏˇauprhimjs"eqȵ ner@PtH ۊJe@`vala A@rwY(rl8߇.׷ٸіHi;'Xhabur`vqicultHc acizllXLtra l^oppos؈rg賗canmXy{GGJПw(barmmotr0у77Ptory)H3sE0ڏyhAurorcycl̃"uhi Ѣ֥сteac_X2tiᵣuIII.ɍ f)[eɢroypin8v@p@qM8Gr’ZLso-cx Ep@lb(puHȵ9 AoProf0@B`ink1I hgi؜۸yˣe8itResingheulleriscussionfheuestfornorlace,illhortlyefendypinby"followingrguments:—

(a)ecausexmost8lpistlesurp toeclahcalgGreekiteraturp geries. (CompB(ley’sorks (DyceEdi).)fJdocisڄ)lealike preservedd*' inved.ԁancixorldwarmwithm;*grea1braytimula(demyIqaimehenɅwasoegxubl0:(books,Yyasicrept؃Q2.b)ׄoneutqaumbsHioumaindؐ|can@!admitgenuinuniisoYp9grou^inkҊP:KbQoverlmevicsquirp||nYpɃIsimiIinyrtiv`I9whoh8iatalXstftoge9.†h,@tЄ0MGrotwouЋt `т EM8PЋ~yewXcRnk;moZa[mo.kchrwHt fromW(ZonРry.΀ +examp;antit9`},0 nu )yei`duccHex20d@yPs'''''''"1rnxprobabihreP(gХ@enorm= P:{triviunmean,Hvoi:decpsubtyو،XPfXيY˕*i(HmaPpu̓ӏ*m@ny1giPsminappri@borrowedQich)amm0p:˓X8` o(ˋhimself9lse;scRe&Law`ycurr4oo3ȱls@@Ċ@(sespecKh,ÈioßJa uaXerunColis)JuAgPsȈa-er `ffecjfaulp#9ersTacIaɁhcAb5obs1irrelev"xsolona s:awk8dątrucwropu仐ds5Ator@xlȄuxXጙ HippnNysaenepheDSa‘havɛwelphilosoph@ abos`,ir0郙ysiȶYurse,’᳸iG)ϲsixasjRgePsfo9llu'"ysA(nimp္tفshowYitcdi@r ȹ;makfact .g.BꐈirTyrzl+}moC f Icinim,hkɰ۬fifty-ŽpalpRepbbsurdJ*olci2s

<0lor="#000">IV.ԅaȆIsubjeco,I rieflttionH shoulpeemٙJoverlookt.r.nPJackhfinColI,am`dYɂОPc̋hcribuЌJ18q9logip@pn(renewxplanaŗbnic ‘Ideas.’(\XRʠ1ttiffPIim8fAw pyoams:iqiɈfBchTRepubl=Phaeda좠appȄheaetet)ebQPo@icarmdTeuHLfiौYy (Ŋth ߀ِjhAșs:Asnex8`@hipm.:Xau lonxhcludufu\8XR,@rТx‚ 8typsPXH*pѵ!xcڥ[ قBᑐ,ajyɇmbtimitTouo\0hw xps!wpio:OONwro޾9 ghtscieGGgז`__Yoއ:IXanapwordz + dxm//7`LwfTуXoPWo!baaArtleBMeta8sic1AQahhaccЈpԺer scholb[imsiblrncPÈepchimselfPepdisc&7ī;zsai=@a QI(Greek)%+ٙgivrmpÂlXL pAhelτ0r^ kInf8Itiˆyne~n߫be׃hakboth.WWWWWWWQWgXpecCxbiyIyAHa aY័ewfash葈doc n*R?8@sc Rk9rpacJg`qxfully;Ibrief 2iobjxrˍ@qkata؂t(1)irst,NYargu1liģ:.‡0w@#8|froʼْx@Dpxoso8cᐹisÃȋsdiaЋilib0`ѴZ(o-hl ktJ# oYprsubƖinfluY`ercX`p񀰃Iuponheorldyristotlendishilosophy.utnhe(r1almostveryphosapabPofnderstpingsubjectcknowledgesatwritPsveotomeowosnu`nticormikei1dialogu؀Plato.owuch$mYbscribedyN’a,dueYsuccessor҃PeripateSchool,axti8whi@hasenetermine`prob0y$cbe, causYoluitpendspinxnalidencpnlPTo ‘heighgre argumȇɋXpooQ etfact,birrelevantyApresscuss,ill󊙀!hopsQxttemp explaȎ N.Ɍ#chapmMeta@sics0otPDr.ʔ8sabtw(ctavoaɃlength,Ir0ccurPn r劊refHʂlthough!hYplcosmlؙex0t:—sm8퉑rruly;HwadoQhrpDr/ybook+Ȟ؇!ׁȁdes8 romonclusabhL؁renera-eliansgns. (Compytrik3markScah+agnaoraHaecuЄshaptitpauctoY8nquamo.)

(2)ԕzZ5ƚ󚠤8scioH(madpxgDPr1PIdehh׈تut{himoMRepublxzocX0akЏPo !rwayӑ7ipGlȂh:Hunfollimx;PsEoՒi1holfas@xoft se`m (Pebu`Phaedo)߈ۖw!Law{KhaprMi(cPmП.;B).Α=Xif3me񩰃،4 (.00 gcB$4¯tsaidt0ru1Zep5Id,firs)lf]De0c0rd do |work,08cل߇ czo moer`gy,wBy+蜁 suphorhor,a,variɊwdefinitadugBpe@xorship.ACsub8(ʭ:(twelfBMe0Y`siʁuwɜdec1Xlifeti`opȽascedPtZBtak1evlfztrmhmlionhlm>  2m}@l ex`ɟtirimihm:ѲK}`2passageounPrs*婬ÂJBH(nQt(knowledge>al(neg sens Zgen,[ular:!jecv"1WHd+ditHty.ϕat h`elli(cA(եEsurlPsȚv;imaeus) #miXʄIexsԍA0romGpoшviewbe) sp^w8qjufie ㎹mȂ0Xf:ɒwAb8XʑiѾPu[{숀aXq)ʼHs5w@ *fesserogicalistinctions,sehouldallhem,heHrfntologyrred0!ichroubledɁ-SocrchilosophynmeoBfrnrxotleXreariously9cussexplained.husaradmi9c`@encyPlato,utourY.eivageefoIsy8madolHpermeatlanguXPHmusatlwaysectqfi`himarrpeme8 cis:—‘poagisutum.’†@truhownext,zcfultud@f܁Yf!valyirX0YÂmrȉyc(iastg.

<0lor="#000">(3)ncluكt DJacksoX YsumHIow9`8modqprocedure.ƌȃtake0ord0i@HregarRxirn蘺piecpffxparhHdiau0yreparbitraryrxlgH< ȅ@auHrndtwossq9so9bi,قx ppea[riing@_po`bvielabj?maysechelabox z.ylseMXremismadJle @!.mZonjhlievebapbe؜ h̡!hiddns;ȏho)gre7`thinkҟ(!d8gb2geh8bt1*roduc𢄭brityhoon(J.9Pl.) r@ʋ>wrots㊨r1scoBYmۀwclouboversydm!yecqui(fix@tYJaih+oq;IaHysoh,seepLaw(ڬʅ؊ s@w҄肐owa+moderе)1 i[咐^bWinssPk퀠self꟰AWnr8/PanidebuBeSs`u(w g,imaeuIyimuleously, B>Њhh;وhn0drrȌ܂(0 8onQccຘمilaNAȖfح:ao0(iB_ьw*i8h@cτreӆ seque#nȇaȈTѪsXyikS$鉪bu rstoxIݫbsaysWA@cg opinxb@ Hتlaarnat.ɞ)cmIm!improb:H///9«untakbmȚњms)pripHtrsed?Ʌtr@P,doPרӝheaxtMe8Apo@p鋐j 9aP&9superfixcepRzawq(orʺyeaПub܃ QyremarkpfurQs!gggPhaedr70ݩ Ҵ؟do`WafoϺȩ͂Ice9kdbegiYn߁aEleftfsheׂҵ$₮lwOtwjk wa\G`XuΉ -ڎz' occu궇us.͠ޛxȟwncribpchnimorelastichanax’ (Rep.),nd ‘whithereiblows,argumentol.Ԁdialoguesflato`eikeoemisoedBseparporkexcepteQyicbyuthorimselfoavnXtionalquence.

It(me dAtakingassagutHrxtrplacQmPewnexnsefirmPprehceiv8 ory,ichefecDr.acksonsocedure.tayemedoughoɎ#samtt oa至ˁ9Fa1!actisso0imPcallxpYmyȀ*rtaQScript,Q؆Ցddsbdro /x81H1`Ans0vfancy?0sugt*Å؇employCSchleiermac9arrang __chrongJaccHo`0rpJtruedeaainq. (Hlscl9,YascZmah fzwrits pendupYt (See.hilol.else.).)waillenuitto:oymboloShspe)adȍanP rcaserr@ ne:—hǓnax߄8thus؎ ptuٔ`rex(4)oLr !oI1Uw1hga؉Ksummaenerall90Ёnow`ex8For0TypSԃPlyۦ9o0@objs:1!ɨ;mper0lways vpo0̧H(' ) HChopOstud*ari3hypo{visclHif𥒓nٌ|"e:dii(|pximreHЃt!gbkح(gB.Š8epublicevPhaedo^less2fuxeitverHl!inn(͵9=umAuȀ(Gk),Var( spiamb!aThehiefdditionsoIntroducinThirdŁ[Xnsistfssays;followingubjects:—

<1.anguage.2.eeclineGreekiteraturoooooook3k‘Ideas’Plaandodernhilosophy4myth5reARepublic,tatesmanZLaws6legeAtlanti'''''''#7.sychgׂǂǂǂǂǂǂ8.omparisljwithӁtA nihBIntu҄mbp:pbreak/>

Admitt⡎׋'ENj,ould8pauЁmeaspš늀tۓgood;iՄσk(1iz1pp;فѪnrsal7teorppXs1:9*br 簯3evil.Ԣ)@Ci(replicietGGCK+ǰregth07k.ocaagaPdiviA]rom(cr؄skʇo0du@ىߪ|samfinipwȋsvjИZafmagUs#A}{iah`f08ʉascertЊ{*΃=Chajaldyscredha:o*t1reOmYLXbܙrou0ithpe[P}///////*IialoguH(1)ԄHGreekd؄AbeautP,viyӾai08bod`1is܂if`; (2trȑzp{f _whoA`@ ji7C;playtim2tory]ThP3a9oerb(``YProtagorHCyluribpienuiЈu]oerpeHaZ`PHؼre80e`ent@cXercro8r4germJn哐c(pcipXIôσ‘do)one’wnus,KRepH(suhifbv=jnphilosophy)n-, /*bce5impJexhib~BFCUqlem؁)!Xludeh(6{beginta`sicsh(twou):Pة*`Ȝo߁2w1youwwuoʀKalsYwe؃_iJŒ2(;) Єkfirw olu-d0}(la(;,)pg`1skuino?)tuggudiffHl:bstʆ)one ofhearliestnticipationsrelsubjecIdZ,c[ivlementnnowledge —0richanquet’metaphysicalux*whqwtastezanyings.(7)PlljmiPo,avhnatchedor`mo2atshadowfuture,ickly`sm:0usysaaconclusth raneocienceisӀnoParH.). (8)Ԃepa~hgoodevillsoiroccurIH3PhilebȂ RepublicsȀ@or(pPoso10eges.

Idramc(9TDialoguXhief(cXqyouthhides,耀whomocrHalkk8spiri2elder.ȍ8ldlik0impity2(enuousnes1PrYddxrhetoHyrCiaQhogrown-upworldaincI.o艰Ygn,p8ZTimaeuinfamyattponamJa8AxnihisH@s[8ulȋders(,슁s|ennobQn c0iSn (X.)XXefollowerКҌplhb`Φsts.ɂcarguYsruiaIaYmadYsxht0endy{3u镈i saxqrhtccompP;\sxtimnЁ!trA n٢قlangu萩beousbe(YruarHVbeauulGklo(qc(acGreek`huAꓢmselfoAfѱhembh􁧒#axa,hapH o8crr!ccoxoenHo(honHUlifere(rHspeaЌBAsy (MeH;򆘢surpȲšޕfwHsczxrtyr𖧪nKaڏJvu`repAIne m̚f:aXap.׏natkeepysecKى;D/=enjoydwYz6eassoI0deA90gre^map .Ґ8ce_,Temdo’pwnusi,*ss@{)jborojaPenquiryY𥘎absXcsuedh0et.;ʼnyd.).0servXcc8ro؎<ne8bhoosjviewvarY8buXlwaxb1lm-xRmsensXQy exпbusdurnȋÃb l0clon.

<@lor="#000">9btprocregulPЉuop los9+firwٿ1qoughZpar p*JhQPЙl;fdelCi!e@>pxЫy@y0enuwyHd`cuequ: h{DrH*ϋȜag aimwчroduilemknowledgPit@ѾPa(ng(scie0.˜2Arrxd iz+*vifetas3su`؃brPؒ"TPe@〈Republicl@P荽nf (Greek HcXe8Iݸlatonnghd8ifihNЖoppos,skqlmo˴?Atotlow Ha@t9Apy?olor="#000">TheifficultyfCharmidesris8chieflyromtwoenၤword (Greek),remperance.Ɓethicalotion>,hsousdefinedoeuietness,oty,oingurwnus yfoodcialogueas:nintellectu@copeNdeclarals*)scieЁself-knowledg(؉whatnd1hevil.Ԇeepre t0tainhistorrphilosophy醻щreyet stuished.ȇZщxfbetweem,Jasypsiono(rDɁ2sċ@fH`all(jPed,ts4observъɂyteYqrAightnatu*at,nlikS぀CrXasVnmmverbbbleimpliqu80@lthougt`ureceiQ8oluS(,Zbalread8nsqdyWmQolearpr1svirtבu3eraintryaps.ɄimiXpi`Qmsaoyouma9ourbKqꦎi‘D[trouhQrbosumattColife;’beiia"den6r: Irutyyitriet)mprovem聙c(

<ϯʃso,ysi9achave#placgPfirserPlatonic: (i)i`horzBcityif[ ʩ sameq`PhaedruSymposium:zbaZf*certHɢ{ڈ eff8@d.craSocP@>;{belol@pذ;arBnolJSаЭ 0vi+o,[tdocoyd&¦wh3cat;rQH(ivyaadhn mp2w Hd؅ᅠiod;#thfulaut!d `tɧL3`(#mblɎɆYa88;ɵeoyhqHartvadeHwdehmJJecat{Ǎwng`K0v(N rgO/ȏ4sccPnӰEdopP2n9`mConvъ 靭timind p# 2@suC/t۸8jof.ͳiBzsubj@C sP=`!alwoul8nYt"QnylikПس؋knowg;agbpwarnɊjCtlsoProtagorE0ydemuJp!tZIiculǂU5 aYiу*뤰o@xRoccurDPHҐseems Was&phiop8]?8mbp:pbhk/>
SONSFHEIALOGUE:oc)wh;ntor,harmides,haerephon`ritias.

SCENE:healaestrafaureas,hichsearAor iKingonY@erdayvenIeturnedromarmyttidaea,ndavbeenood!lxway,HthouЀ@Ixldikeo2lookohaunts.oweinh1povergains empqdjoiڂ*irefoupaumbxpersonmowhInew,utotl.yisitasnexpectednooondiyeeenP;analuЀbafopllides;ψyoiaiЅ@madmastaraupr!oЀeizЅDsay,owRyouscapSocrates?—(Ƈ@lsengagemhaXak@c_loBfowea+J yXsbonlyꖸ`achAns.)טטטטטטט҇ЖAli ڑam?oooooojّaqort,(iZ80AanPfupcqutanfeυυυυυυaXʎQtruthuppos71wYpres@؂n(toweus@stor0ye؎Yve+h`dmf0lytᩲ;ss𛸢by2ٹ쀣xȭchru iwI=hi3;acomp!à70ans1Rir#alquirie?//////? h놉en#iI,X)egȄbohmatppopPԌztposoph ^إskH9(*Rremarkab80sdPbeautQXoY,lɤdoor!viyt0i8s9rs*Ђ i algX؃efollow蓈arowd.ϑ+Bム`1-iHp`Ȕdg).Ƈth@aVdvduygt؂oq!+like off!selfW؃hZy; fa?Ch`h|n;D0cousuncGlaucon:1Jndknowx8l mgPnpUti` repare ertlArv+n{ (Xp؉18HimagiZ*mYlmoPaqmanOOOOOOOJYfeoJawproxs"hmaX;.ȫscarcorЈړ[edNh,1fnЋ*IanmeasIygӟlcfulammpYu1߯l1ch(;Պponppeney±r(K!{onf4ѵastonishQ( X ,hme@hmazЂ!Ѡrn+쥃aroop)lou.ԅɟJ-Hurselveshouldaveeenffectednhisay soturprising,utbservxthat(ererPameeelmo0boys;llfm,owpoveryeasthild,urnandookYtiHifedtatue.

Chaphonㅰisaid:ׇdoounkSocrates?ȅH0a@auhulace?OOOOOOOIMo,W B9wk@gs,aliecse`8na9form:iabsolutelyer!υυυυυυυApH yagree777777yeracles蘚nesuch(paragonsnonehdditionGGGGGGGBRat?:r(as///////*Ia blxXberousmbexpc '''''''"Hӕirgood0〉out,_______XThebehLbody,5sk w@X,Ԇaundisguised?LaHg(thiwilik(Halk쭉#hpQIȰe3{ osopalreaalsoconsidpoe0!opinڃ PbOggggggg,year?Itincь%xl!BfamiinxibybfromH.†whдk9\quhvqjwQng`)%nompropriety]resencj,hguardiasi7OOOOOOKVeryH;nXbݤturnattendanXCharmԕЁcomH`Iysiczbh:@nes8fOspo+!dbyester.ԆQaga@0ged:hhplp1la:avaadac!6mo:w5mbeBpk(uqqe?gggggggyI;22AgggggggҘHsTʟ$7wwwwwwucaAbwyiы8d!betw9me.ǩmme occas+x@pusgr텙;"sQrorJlaH1Ynex rmselvuntila9twondꀁrP9hagetp+BrolloPways.΁Ifnxbeginfeewkw;Rorm(bofpoXʲ@∺х vanishPtyBZ@joђloXnȠ`PinPcribmannerӂrgoask(qu ˋZ [op%alar8 Х u#,!:uȀAinp Ё*fl8ĂHH @tAmy`f.t!1y`s snaвlpeaa8irthns ‘9(brrawaYev`C)’I`lIr"xorhd-bea`appet[1nt|ˏ$ьfhknewmeansbutithnffort,hatidnow.

Andist?`aidIeplied3itasiofeaf, ichPquirYoeccompanbycharm,ifpersonould9etBksamei) usr@ure,madphole;u withoj݀QɁφPnovailThenwillrit@G@fromourctation'??????>Wynsen8I,r?σσσσσσσ·,ocratesF,aughingσσσσσσVeryooc;areyuasш1nWWWWWWooXښ,(X ar1dealb amongCmembepchiseeinycusCiasLJLJLJLJLJLJamlajfiVvm9`haXAioo腊:X;bettHablPoxplaxnatț؊rsIelt@difficulty@e.ƌ<do,Àidnnl@ceadach sayhavrdminhysicians[0XPesY8bey anno AhPselvq&!ᔈц1teng4yinkPonЂ)rebodlso,!сfolly.guځHwڄ appXidc tٛ2lWrgper.ĜPevpobser@لhVGGGGGGBY_rA)aP!熟certpه?______ZHpprovɛ wersasI@g`deɒ rnfnclvitt0Hned.uch(Enl0 8hfromx߀ThraZlxiHIkHssokilfu7n!niim@itTIto{bsottir҆QmH eNjk+sa@B;jddour򇫐ȺoPur, ‘K mpZ橂)탐cRneɃ YM)ulŇ8’υĖon*{mIdis`unkHella)ecau`(oraГ$J͆tudiVn@wP`lesӪ!.!gooxevilzsPxhuhigihXdecl`YɞsoflowJinԐIeX󷃀ж,⺼y_lfng~,QthكJeffecx`;s耓ZfawordsPe c:implol"JhspeediH茱o! ˟GDKaJ̭0ai(2x(lrxh:Le !gdsuadecuasirstivenouisouloeuredyhhharm.orxis,’eaid, ‘؁9greatrr@ofurayntmentဉhumanody,physicianPeparatAfromr.And1addPwithmphastami(making퀠wea@owordx Letone,oweverich,rblPfair,ersuade҂X9 ,ou;NowaxsnP0IusteepyatɁreforefbwillll8oppl+ThrasirrCstrangdirecte(Ifterwaroceȃ'܂head.‡ not1doQnwIሰoɍ,!d)CQides.

CritiawhГ9PQ:PdacH—unexpaoQrelatiohYp1i0mpelh9omsinScHteRSoc9ؘsJonpre-e აbeautyoequalbXHxiXwhH{rm;Ds"saxePce?YaIJn@moȤ( eȇ@Xagnferin y,ӑМ1InkouxexcelQgoodDiIbmistakcѓQs1whould媀oiɦwonYs遀selikeoaduc tc,RQaspr(.х f@erIALce؎qtnDropidKfamI(؞xmemoa1negyal@PAnacreSЮHet @z-Xvirtu dꁫhxItۇm򇟇adXuishedrnunc1Pla@repu!nfPnЇiarfۻ2nA:)rlaciaHambassado`AxtوA;[l橤aQy.av0ustoȚpnwe@,Glau(,KᅑmhonAm.ɀHY:Bd@3 شcdeclʲeػW0lessat(*)yl.Plp۠yŖڀr3fCd8Ьepghca0nxqc"Z lx9bar HyboН$I؜s0ϕ񓑗po;J؄yacquir±LmHƋe༡(edic.l؎+rZXђ8mruth馭؏@;—˗heIȍ?xuenhCkmo8ёpth;Ir)@ngenupl 0+8eiz quRIsked:ƥhfhm˼a`hgȇhoymyselzsoJ 8Kxktʄl2:y Zash3aiviPn; sHd`XknowhwY.ggggggga!im:Ԇia٪'#25gen/Wb `BȈ p+ځ1 liknIe rashractitionerfedicine:herefore,fouleasxIillhare9nquirythQ,ut=not0ess"\woulda).

Tshinghichpshlikeetter,Haid;ndsar9Imncernedmay8oceinw iksoooooookIA,xahad$8gbykyaauH;ortemperabides1b vnpin؁@o8x;e#gi somntima!Batu؊Yquties,enablekomH0.ɍ‡;true?gggggggaYqNpiσooooook(knowq҉languag3aNWb)X8te wifeeląsCertainly&;rdhnTru@idǂǂǂǂtolor="#000">Andhich,aid,setter —acilitynearning,rifficul߀?

<߄F.YesE;؆ fquickly,retlyzslowlyTruewitottoeachothenergeticalrathanχυWWWWWWWćǂwwwwww_,Amin8IhremembOdadiHׇׅgggggggheormersshrewdnessbcleversf eoulÁсzet ߄߄߄߄߄ߗWstunderstQwhatwhewrit-mas ’ʀmusicǢanyrelse,+ssossiblbu咛gwwwwwww]nKpchЈdeliationgbq"simagin8AhopthyeЫscoXxthouPorthypraiтdosoeasZWQuite,iׂnPyconcs剠pbodrswifbactiv aar(]vCX2ς߂߂߂߂߂ߨ픈emp@6 r{C@lif,—ertainupo)view;oupezbHpgood.wz8nZna*@yldom,ZXjappЃ"s;Jno0;bm艤΂vehnt:tilPnf0 iq?w@r@'yxJΆvpwalkiy_nyꬲ; ϊr`ˎ֊funseeadmidya:+'havshXs יייייייIbkv,ocjyour!σσσσσσϝr,harmidITfix1tȔhlook:in;!seffechϊsyfnatuڇxہ.ԉ!I,kbrth me WGh''''''fYa’sauASadreaax :ͲpinXgd/Hkhammoъ򁟘s`JZyzVi;Bdid2I,0wDž/7YnσCdjlsozgWt="0pt"idth="2em"lign="justify">Yes.

Andanhateoodhichoesotakeen?Certainly1ǂǂǂǂǂdžyououldnfertemperanceoble,utso?TكmypiniongWell,aid;sureagreethom`wh`heys,_______Y‘ModestyjforeedyPn’烧m,[IcXuppose3m/aPgσσσσσϘlearly_B,0prese) xy,bahlwgׄׄׄׄׄׄי appso(1has:@Gwwwwwwt‡چȠˆt—f'aGׅmu(evilkdžWWWWWWSll,ocrata??truePhliknowPIthinkboQhhdeft 1I0wemembioavearromВГÝz,ڂdoingurwnsiness.׊0rBaffirmeat׊׊׊׊׊׊עhmonster!s zCraphilosoph@to8ׄS$lsHn,u;jcI;777777GAatharmi,mьNὑreplie0p8Aword8P*(yr[P!in:2߶:4߃߃߃߃߃߃߃۠surMyeQdoubw(h`ppbldisco8i0ruthfa(haip`riddloggggggcWAwso?цу_______+ecau))ueeemWcmea`)gۓڪ.ɳycribexamplzreg8@{AxnKads9weׇׇׇׇׇׇӱۋ1!do Qzteaboy'"رnamhoXd0{2enemieskwe8@>jfriendqsuؑKōт(nykdljr4Х  CςǂǂǂǂǂdžόЦpip؆ai bՑ(SjQbusines7wwwwww׳Wheamesoing.

Andhe hngrt,yriend,buildsweavnzPythIwhateverHich酁ney—asHlllearlyxundLdf?OOOOOOOICertainlydoouink0att8oulHexore`awpȉyano*8yashPownpamak`shoesÀflaskstrigilormplementoprincicُ derformy,abxinfrom"notM?IT,HaidBuIeriiPa-77777772Ofursereplie7Thenc0ɇ Ӑ ’business;0s`wayxr̠fsort?sHǂƏsXwyhwhoeclazGaea!ځdd`mea ;Iѐxhbesuaol1r.׀toP,ha8des׉׉׉׉׉׉NgcouЇhmwi0PImui`puttsdeftiXaHlPno*SkYtrds ‘ss.7777777dؔoj75?ÀRqmendean;ꥠYwo Ȍ9hselfusj1hradiuqx0Heup la(ilyl聡lookCr`asGlohowun؋,fel3Ruؗ)pwi(6Rrexcompany.Ȃb`oweЀHЂynagorы;ӥƚP1 xbconvidtrulsuspic!whiIntげimYΈ)hXanswbo護romtwa(xLl,jkeE$rPpw0xt 1refut grew0grdappXZ,clR quarre `; poet핁?9XactQspl`Zoems0e(esozP*8sah—OOOOOOOIDoimag@A_Ǡƨ'"ůeca爂GWWWWWWRWhaagXx,o0excВ "8be peciG{{olhav(tudmapassumk_sDHoraa Dccep kmu`raхgul hݟ}alsehoowwwwwwT`i@ys,'''height="0pt"idth="2em"lign="justify">Veryood,aid;ndoweteepeaPyueHon —ooudmit,sw0asaying,hallraftsmenakeroomethH?

at!askePX!mean9hk)ZЄmeׄmorرXliex>;Pusuchhalearnedromesi!7iDdisgrace.Nimag聛ifhah@yڀQs9J)wdescribR™Ij׷ꄟP(bexampl@ˈnufactu eslpicklsittahiYn(Зill-fԄ,otZ0osupd:IXixhimچ YuHp<ϊ;Qildm6ny1im8bec`za8loymet`nourab)]@uҁr#nyall.ƴzBnoblyj fulhmAc`؂s2 sU8fp쓯IjurtpCف=::P5шR؃h,yohAҁsWWWWWWROraݚso0QdȡXruthlIetwnew;RjChiȆ(DPa{Áf,oose:QǃÐӶG18mtgCnds

Ayouayveryikely򂱄what*areay;utamuriouknowperimagtteenboHtirwne?GGGGGGGAPoBthinko,xhido//////oete,Ȁw,scraftsQmBah’sk,HellA6扏ggggggwas*repliedbisrrifthave(articula,,wishwouldxmeahysiciao esatieYhhimselfXdso ЄPdosDhxdutyO______ZYe'wwwwwwυRyקت0PP777777z`'Bmnecessarintreatrprobenl?у>??;H糚tedǩbY0ichtljljljljljǙsuppostǂǂǂǂǂǂT,sometimСxharmsI;,9`jhdoɖ.ׁkSrt(y''''''7wwwwwwwsee?:Dy[' P AdomWance!,optimsible;ұefoifahyxnseque)fyHevioudmi @wihwithdrawa(ȵiHnra`n N=7c[Imashamehf`ȏerror.Ƃȁ-aledgQcertainh@mPqӈveeFPgretimKedicXscript, ‘Kt!’telphi.Ԇa8ftakp:؎Ya8rt salu0gaddrIPo):sspȀ@Pہin7pHail2ЅYr#exh(BeڌӋaarHtwŝa؉I"DϋϋψaIliev8)speak,Hn;A,ashipȁۃfirhearyAhow8r,`pheRex8ridd1GGaXIsЉ,͎Kl£B(Gk)6 HeasundtSsucce8sagQN0oR,oGiv2'vil)daPphasy;jimagRŠixdviPoAgXᙗAGir4cominyTQndea8[givequallysefuliecesfdvice.halle8you,ocrates,hysaythis?ybjectsoeaveereviousiscussion (in0ich@knowoterqrareo(right,u(atnyX,Presulastained)`ndaraiseewnewiemptYprovif2deny,(erancself-ledge.

Yid,ritias;Ʉcomop0houg)fessejzaboqueponsaskӂIulIwagree(th .׍eeatInquihm8xItruRCXdromiA, ecado;`nh)̅pђmԂX.Б(nPDreflxR,( ߂߂߂߂߂߂߂ڇ0mingQrepliyٖrgc,ywisdomimplyhny8mˁscieb}qs8zω;twwwwwwwsmedic`σhealth?σσσσσσσTru{Asuppos'wPibywɞeɐeffXgшwuJlns0Ɂ`hy`tZ0dugFJsZdminxce;ωωωωωωωGte_ңskAǶLߛrchithur{(ildIPs1soIoartZi9Zirprss.Ψ葘ޒh83imilh=ccorYߟ viewqA0bgooorH0thyeaPdoe@׋??f,?m?????? d䅐@pursuy,ocratfn]lik솬yohyeopa:ڝ9cexS.ƃtʄ܊Ácomputajgeцꍁsenak_[ߓaarmweav·Xٶw?ÈwsuXWhm?ف(can؏׏׏׏׏׏׏׏׆ُm;eaP subjqޞ'fr8W I3y (doptddvenumber8bericallꉡvhတ[Ʉhe)غoYWWZooŠon_̔w9ZagainȐ߇hhtQr& 00t.İr??????Mwwwwwwr`jkn'@6Q!ט߅''''''#000">You areustallingntoheldrror,ocrates,eaid.ouomeskhatisdomremperanceiffersr؂(rcieandntryoscov99respectCichyyalike;utnot,("ofthelse;؀فmselves;aloneMI׆_itf.{0selievpaI yePaw:thonlyoI*denieGH#now,Yprefuteinsteapursu argument.

ifam?owaLkIavnymotix҅!1Ihou8examinmy?ltwbaear9myncon0ous`fӃcknewwI8oHtsqi*echiefI ownkhapdegreIsoQq܉frds.ƁAI=@:ngs[tru oodmonmand?Ycertaiע׃gggggggaT,I,cheerful,weetighp an0hsquePЏͧenX0Criti0XIs8d;xtd5sت܌#aIr"repؗdpsbsay_______ َWmeHYffirboj7777777EڰԱ?AS+DžDžDžDžDžDžDžB/[_˜oabs҅ V`@em؜PӍN 9ma8gPHfera rrastXZeu+Savi,촘beggP,iH@pla1ui*possi ܌㌷ބ|secophffectuuؑnyǍݒeaXsid">؇(ܐIopQfiAi@culty[gmy.hHtQYnatuPĂg//////y0anreplieGD].beȻВamouk:~8m B󁠘Xwhoq-p׼Ѯhm׹׹׀ԌO777777͋wwwwww000">Butonsiderowhtroushisropositions,yriend:nnyarallelase,emsibilityilleranspentoou.

Yes.wwwwwwwqWhichsess,鈫o(redopr? TsureAndYwauldisomethingatitself,dπɈHbutotOIthoqiso >0r,  ha`proper(Hbe ՅyalsoRWlfoNJNJNJNJNJǍk,ocesaidqevitzinfere莿O aouaۈpӀ󅸀pwill9halves;o,xreoҁPwwru7 󑂈iρheaviȁoiٕYoldwsyounger:tm+;Gh0atreta"lìPject:eqay,examplerisyJ8sroiɚX______gwwwwwwwؙA|it耲ʗnowa LClys,y8cellePfrien ْ j`yuiScanה҉ {NoooooooojDomark,ritiaqnveral٘`beHrecitɛotiapAltoginadmissi cas@hardlyred! —Ohmagnitud9numbMkWWWWWWSVeryBu*1AowФX-mB 諈urGregЖpinFbymbperhapqtɎs.(hhx.0an,pos(sfactoridemine2uwhˤ7pnpprotʅPjA+;2clasx<—ڂ1suscce?ca(isdomtema)ldrishownPmatsamcˊwu%\Ѕ@ڇ=,shoulacknowgڸh,ntil 1ńKadoyoodIÐAmpreHפAnefPaʂXObCaeschsm0R)J]abs'$Ireque`howfirplas0sayb,ilityVsecopJdvagxa' 0Cy4ar"priewf*dI@sawۉ+a@fficulty;nd asneersonhennotherawnsnisresenceatcheshefectiofzingromm,oideeemoeriv(inxafficultyyyy.utshadhreputama , w@ashamedadmitpforeRcompany`atcouldonswhchallengeretermi؁quesissue;made`telligiblttemptahierplexiIrdargumentightoceed,a(JW nritias,ouike,etasp0t1sciB\;Bpjprjwromayreafqinvgated.t)QXsteit,iYI툰owuchenas!dxuish(`wenoyhich,qayЈelf-Aledwisdom:?

YeSocrP1HˌInkcerYlrue: hϊirc€PtI3beebXҁhwswiftnesPEbeau -zifulOLObyr7߄ow*f).GGGGGGGAIUdoubМ,a@possє:hnec0ْavi|h*ҏDdoMBecaushy@i7zVeryzly;IYstup`Pever;:IaioRre𔸉ȚڒD 1/w|3Қ{LJWimean?'''''''"TI:Hlied:Xں{oW;—㘈m:two gs҂j٧w?No,ׂǂǂǂǂǂǘؒԳa0Ѐhhealthש'cGCGǂǂǂǂǂǓmedicOpolis;reŇP(speakI׈pu؂simplAHif̭{oLЀq߀h/nour_w9$robabi0<񃎀some aCZJco@rn<#men''''''''a1yteaimA?ax ¦iwisdomtempera,:)arEtauoقZzlearnermonyrousic build'#,:ei,3:#knjnjnjnjnjnjnjĊXhevidenׂׂׂׂׂׂHm,gard@jRπY, 76,:πȋծO߆߆߆߆߆߆IPossib߂width="2em"lign="justify">Thenehosgnora(ofhese0ingsillnlynowatis,utot0s?

Veryrue.

Why,aid,erearooeadyPdmithe瀠tenefitshichankindouldbtainromireverallyoingJthP ynew,@comt_Zofwy@ignorathoshobettercquhteitm.

Yes,ean,uthe1oYssell.ǃǃǃǃǃǃǃaid,whonowsastndreseCertainlyot.

9unohAth;moc)grerxonȁ8itЉoٛ:ngo Psup`)Xficb!in3OOH:|resulsb"am9nmuRl !,xkysak`Charmh؂(yQ0—x,1sbeau适ĀGZ, 7fiPrlifr҂eÏ˦mgri(jcIxthp3ott@,KYThra` k ith.%deyist"Sm@aȗcѬ )Ipl|reȔA(᪋happJaertA0p.ׅxamiX!ùe1:gif)dd "0adv9KX!)foolousS8ғЄ ȤAilw9be.

<lor="#000">b:s9 H,oc I Djɚ/KYIRd,*ڂhCr 9@say,1?(#].)RވN< Ԕ۩OOKPh8PPdail"enough'''''''"Vɝ7`=;Ў\ 8JOi`75g xXi@0llYm(depemy11*0e:whoreyuardianommande,houldeeryrongotobeyou.

AIo6,aidGGGGGGGBThenHwillqasI(y,ჰbeginhisdayYYirs,hatre2conspiriHabout?׃׃׃׃׃׃׃We27,*harmideweave%edread/______W:us@iolencwittvhgothrough@eormsf9ceG1arepliesiorders;rehatterrlloB@timƒNationsasssmployed" Xdeminpanyqj8oofwirresibleDoB1noooooooi\l Ie_Xmbp:pagebkW3TTcen`MsizePDŽ666AwebdiZpublish(by:??eBooks@Adelpew:brX)GGG@ԍUniXsityibraryǂDžgSh`ra 5005w'ak/> NMody>INDXTAGX 04IDXTINDX00ۀ019Մ02YnĢ03Ht̀04<ڀIDXTTopPreface to the first edition.Preface to the second and third editions.Introduction.Charmides, or TemperanceFLISAFCISg