On_Sophistical_RefutationsNONOBOOKMOBIU+$+3;C KY S,[ibFj3qy, "$&(*7,M.ٮ02d4d6/8:<Z>@ 5B(BD01F8H= J=L>N>P>R?"T7o$MOBI?G%  +P')(%EXTH&e*The University of Adelaide LibrarymOnophisticalefutationseBooks@Adelaidၩra( 2007mbp:pagebreakp647771}66hTebdiqublish6;aref="http://ebQ.aT.edu.au/blueuGEuRenderintoTML׈׈׈wwwdirectory/stephen.thomas'''~Steveԁgg??ggggggLastpdW Aug 25 15:51:39107777777774םGGG@peniversityfibrarǂDžgSouthstra 5005wN_߀G???B?6džZǁ>OOK߁߃߁ILJχș!Owv1ww??LETsowiscussopPticefutaas,.e.hatppearoe'nsurally0aciesHad.HllginnatuPr耹first_X\2___somsoningszgenuine,iler8eem$s0notXsvnt.Ȁphargumalelsew throug0ertalikenebetwꄤndsham.orhysic jpeophaigosnKφm@ylowriggmselv itribes oirctimssacrifice;b73beau(ulank-yGE,IdQembellishWQ.t0poinanimpP;Z0sQZr2tgold2煦ucxoȑ e.g.41l ȏHK;psey(met l*ɒcsawaKB @xxperiencQy kɅso:Wc0Dobonlxxwa9taview|restnfte̟y8vo ec`ari8ass9az h(bE:(s4dorҽhonclus.Ύҁm,achieЅȗ%iauʄHOostrol1usudom)ҧD,urupnlyAmpossibХ"\rۂctYLwe0Psymbol!eIp( pfoɁ<,nhehingssell,ustqpeoplehoalculateupposenegardoheirounters.utwses (nam8anz)reoPlike.or+finipsoszsum-totalforme,i8in(number.nevitably,an2󃈂WzaHi,av8

C;ond눳biY[aiphh،.eswT耨yډ"!0ix'!lenSڎ񕀅^br薘,pinquir'toqihba8 3RcPersize="1xb2w?"1??//>OZdxogu—hfoues:''Didic,ăȦy,xaȸ-猺C .Kȿjciroeaopine [`Vnp)t9jr):zׅׅׅpr)eXy!ept"diaivyis:0Y'$<ȶȠ1`oaledg6A>)-w`aedefXtt:JoGGGAa)(clgePu )so1>݇demtHgGSYAnalyИZsY? sew:0ceɇk_uetiIӌ:iϩ77777377?7???Firstm(raspimsIta!!Pٲyrivalydhi.,fut,llachpa`ox,ismKfifthHrducopp4abbl -i.e.ДhhiYtqselɈtimAi Aro֙C(j"Bwixylity.ƪyhoifibpl؇%؇$2ty,rs theecondestohowhatesommittingomeallacy,rs`irleadimnpparadoxjfourthly1reduceBolecism,.e.makeenswerernXnsequenofrgument,usngrammaticalxpression;0,laporӃqrepeimself.

4w?"1??8justifyETh(wtylesrefuton:rdonlanguageqd,hil Ayinsm.howayBpropra@!ch?sixnumber:yambiguitPamphibolXpbin,iviɃwordsXc,m.ϒwe(ssu@Xvbothy!ucayyllogicقbais-9itb8sumpQll-҄:ˆX{1 "eahn(rns.,su8owup. ‘ronowXꐒԂirxt`ۓdicȆxm’.Ƃcous;ysifi-`y8rst聡\!`ledge#acqui*AgaiEvilgoodwneedoemx$bɂih2doubɌX:`񁘑nta(oftencp9o (q!kp_Y)chQs #ޱ.oreovAҔms9i3ick(healthsIs@jmc,r9u4څqup ɀwWā]dopo8*0Ɓ8nhonongqti>͈i񉑀X0~erly`cҒo̢|ѿ饐yϑӂnjkڑSen R{B(,Ԁˇ.x89GGGC:qI0shyouenemycapt8+1ZhesiXswso€hrObeloaY11,y0)ׄ֬`yes:Vpilla(ergKz >Wf-bǀ:a9ڀڃs-5Speagq[llcpswwIWWSW҂Qрlicso.Ԍqthreeariڏ•T: (1)he@JxprxijtrxHmA$,.g.eto[xdo; (2)Hhc omɆ3woraviatɁg1conatx;letterAea0٠ؘ_ꆘ,y$ogeok-ޏselvב% yel m.

Aݑ{y24pmodXech.թɌ_Ȗ,inc)ABcaalkѐittritߖ6if*diviYccmAsaya…0 q--tgg]appAaHo0τ΅orite-while-not-writing’:orhenteanspateaaeowe oendotponce;hereifeoesRcombihm,GBnii[ԃs.lso, ‘Hewqtlearn؂`letters.oreover,yrZsayQ2pOslAɂyouan rryrowdtoo1

<lor="#000">UponivisiIepeJroposo5a23,:oddKgXQequal(:(amou mPesides.ƐӉHmhraseoulbAou8waypo0v:9Q"dedBe.g.IadliрhfrmanXxGod-likechillhleftiftihundrme Anrgut)uacc1xnstrucnnYtscusI;ɀsjpoetpӂier.hus ()o1eopedȀrgaiih`!cizs`naturalexpreʅ0uataputaimbroyldifficulbjhangf, n`cuthu)S%assaPaboutgmnos𢠄[aXZediChimselfWa2mfulfiljX)prayerRb}b䃣4ihIa8sucpsen0urua1OsEow:o+ormsٜRwȆllyJ@񐖚@t҂apl femi耠erP,߁'$neeс71;x1|a@i@BwӁntvipsaZactiH*iworrPaZsoHr҆-eviouslyadownCsiboIwdexbelo?clМ3llaaɅӣ'!flourisхYчRi,it0ɭ@I!builI:eopÃAcern-i.e d-`:Nd ᖯnQE Refu1NҿluҼdrawn@o`m`plaru.f授acie+pxxinSă^asevhkHs:LJLJLJLJLJLJLJ(1)++8Acci{2yeqb@ yڝʓӂP pexȌBtimKrelRWWWWWWWS3ωωˁox@Р rKgggggggc4gg/Psequ_5uHrig l9cluY???????;6)rqcaٱ5! 7;mag1moxh `QnXWa8 3zcersize="1xb5w?"1??WW>F'ccuen@nttriȺ0m,DaBxqasish d񩱐 ePslsldJ3redمPiubjHwell/(,IfØ8scbeifferentrom “man”,esifferenhimself:ora큑:rIfbe߁Socrates,ndvI,heAJyay,y`ha0dmittedatoriscus>lbecaustoppens (accidit);HersonwheiLh(m)wq.

ThodedneXrxpressidbsolutelyincertaPXpectnoXtrictloccurnevׂԂJparticulartakeHhoughwok,.g.99argumw `objYofiopinPwrbȀsaming!tox`ꀕ.χgPZW;,@f'oikifUwq.yFWWWwtll:9lookȗЃrɗocl n`߆.e.O9buHl֊/EikewihalPwithySurup蜪oiЗOO ?$ThHSuppIndi8 black1Hwhitxhqe;ۨ#bo{]r hcharactlo7˃\˨_cprart@:limTiUso8caseasise`bЌonsmi+pseؖ t 7EH{󉙂askgggXډƅ6儻clu que8orexdrPd8alicyw‘?9Xoftpasundeted,iz:s؞OamadbgXouldqgXrf/llowBwellGEich 뛪dd.ituaɕa(eⱲ1lбSÅsserqHew0r`wɆ0+iraneer:ahalёzH?

ORfaci)5ms)of8xuPhaveRbdefinqmlefhs0iri.Ҋʀh#dp*Ħˏ-mpz𭛀qrety-⎫,synonymo̓*ڄk۸$rogran"nec lX!dckonrigin@siP+a3ed`ݎabIhCGwaSpeoplhow msaid!dtAgi+apأ?,󂰄i()Gݠdoubl{whsYWK.(mayńHܑ򃟃O_Dž|0lengxb腟+ O`@:ӏ" pkvio@crئ;yhlgroupdepЃxlanguagٶz.ϪϪϪϪϪϪϪTho  ump?j˻nypۤ@siib7;0eagȭlmenackheoweroeepheiryestnceponhxisamenddifferent.

THrefutatiichependsYconsequrisbecauseopl`uppoxtYrelof08xvertible.orene,>A@,ecesslyy)nValsoif)A.hlxourhqdxpiPattpinbasexeH-peofbipbeonsi2byellowur:Rxiaraicgrouwence,g,ta)ing;9redo(notg`fo).ɁhetoricroofsromgxareHuiawishashan*ndulak1lfH 'ousifviz.smartdred,!observ8w@(abouɄȇ,w#yxȃ@truih2 hargnuepЄunAypyHll)so;e.g.elissus’gum؊ uni`@eHnal,၈m75aacq(fhjo"Hu0s0ye)‚рzdairstginhfJoOOdn_Yve.82GGD:@ vx0alwaysOȂjρϊ/);0yȄXtDLؚt!˕1Pg___________8tr8ccur//yirt̘G*ougsziPkiyQ[)d3me3zzdemoXh`prem𩉗lnCf8` 0reck amo؁) mpostabsXilitywillpǎ7,+ı‘l҈ xKX amfq-to-@tr|p`Ipiculaorm.hav8OOW ؃u:wXathڂO_oZ:cˁ0Ȥˁ@ o*Occord8l____[.Σ҂э1)l&dasa|;aubm쁝7^6bS/.?†inclus1absolut1l[=onذ1*O``mselvfailit:mu`seoind77777772SXmIר>ssepX¦_ThXegjwo犘xiglurP8@cAa nswretur9Y@o/Pnhca‹- HH3IXڕHD ye8h*iPsea(csky?9lȅpeoprW^eiIf!hirfby mWo8ex;:pAuIsB manڀY`\T8anyhB,Яstrika((Q),xʑk).υgaiؒhЮYgooۀbaX8DwhoP腒F`evere says,tsossiblehateight ouYtox8eimselfanpparentefutationrmakentlyals8em:[Xsomethinggoodhichqnot,mۀHփws.ӂimehowever,ddialremissesyctualgiveiXenuin;.g.upanergratdescrips ‘te’Hdndblinpp`onumbers鋰i0sense.ƉifSbpa*canseatu`ignedeewilllso-~mdo.henӀnh~XBHah rykeib aej;/imM.

6w?"1??8justifyET(rway-؈Iividproof0pbov0)ocfH(GQi񜺐ourrt-poi]okalyqa8esaipo8lacybreach˛fin an.nfirs0 `w؟i0conclus`Ѐ-ultro ldowppcompelecessari3ɚme.expld{ts0bby9trebyiilanguag@peupHaHumean(,ambiguityjordhphra(Jb ms (haX3speakqy Iaculaub8)-_@bihZiacYذbecauyBque0tРșlP9saw 00ed.ve v *,p[Uifi(ell`?XeffecteȍCؗernouudrawЁ,cloakې P'wrubuXtHsbeXxvne(aur򌦚9qkId ssfnwhykhyBkQ؉70ү427772F܆Accڌle8cɋI[xenchix!2iJҔYhogoob tooxcepa0nxltradictorydxρ؁xڥ\f›regayn󁷁Ljssup8:*AB,휡CptodѸD[Rou Jyllogism.ӊtriHitـpq twP-ӄp 8Qimpxtɍр +ma˂AhararOdem@hRaboÄyr;ъ.̳w񣲟j,ϔo蒩rgu(chzhp(|Цj*Iׯ38yexJdsgenerur؁haunʣicklateT#swithaso apȇ/(;d incY@sayQYesiXelpeoJmav id?8ltgh1ypOOOOOOOJTh#/upomHa㎨aPrespX8aabsol8ly7773Iaffirmationndheenialreotoncernedithsameoint.orf ‘whitenertaPrespect’negations񁯁,leXabsolutelyitgc,.f,nanreatsadmissthatthingׄ׆aoughwe`saioeG,芸oeseff(refut,ut8lyppearoowxignoraxw.

<@lor="#000">Tcl8esas؃allXoweverx s1X*previous8described|dependQupQfini񋱆:al`whyy{cbnB}producecau( o'+qiЀivideacitabove9nHtsetDei(ω @ommmark.m׎׎׎׎׎׎׎ԍassump}jriginhjrsAP29 З!;Zs`*lenchirڌxreoflurF :xp2Hqohnh)tagPuld/Atakn accouW[argumen0PchOHbegx////////////7////ߒ/////////////////////////////W////////////////sequaAhqAccnfm1,ndifrom3is,Cyouecu`dtׅ\on܃(e.g. rity+yellowT9hȿP`tMswan)PQMalwayvolvpmo~CPclai8b3`Yɑdy geo))gߏ\g|.Ɏ,wev$tru@suppރB7Ceres;"bHysnow40?:s.ςQMelus@ioYhabegeneednen؄njngQ al_уmag0udK ݫhׄрgIsWgon9X ea'".ikewiii73mad41߃wrÙ_ᆨ7'7:.e.onasmuchonׂisȳyncRqƳ!27?;'#Whalfury exami;ZTHwPwwwwwwwwHaciųDžmXs (xourilidc{deԜhproaleYbрΒƃgppl yǴ'thing’,imply,.g.o ‘manndone@ngleannly likewiselsotherases.f,hen,A$propositioBbeehichlaimsxdth@fWQowilluttNquesqthatind.ow!c`startsromonrefutaBi,toodROMׂtementbou0_ZityobviousЅallacy9pishignoraI wya:orRthno9nppear2w20swerphasturnediough"r'on;q`ifeYarey≁pparт2Š`.htype@f͇eyndߊ߂ϊ@ omm cautradic󘃄;tivrkKא(s؇r0il`PmYefinR.

<᎐ze="1xbcolor="#000">7w?"1??8juxfyETcepcpX–BJrgudepembiguity*ordhphrɍwxunabyo@vid{3e`(y@eas!TuA,ibejYaaess)jy oz+binQs2upmaknffwhe*ʈa+r\dhHdeȋwitho.̲G __c loPra+voihupEztڣlPan-any,فi.ׅɄexp!乹ga.ƫharӔxshi;ДsifibPRsawh@dٍsxacznexpo㧺ndruthpecialisXwh:lihurrinssQ5چp/ver8reڂԃi蔀uHڅp`2$:p!eubAce܎ Uaс֙jelPol}pm lo@fullYspi* ooIٷXWzk)mapage;i @ 7zect4mdixثSinquiSa0mapoQ pourvȬappcapIech񐰍O1؂Phmuwobj0);P`divILhimږy˄1basfpa :"op_r0pgc(w_"1g`?>Ī8iP7dAcc nt,w _ۺ󏙬.pirXhJmultiplic⬶ڤwhavy҂HCoquOɀ1aPM.͎nRzpppea`poХis-clai(adiipfrom,)*BEmXb#defi apfuta,betweaalKabsoluhptynsmFObnvod;y*miʼnula*krniٍ0d"Zg@鏰sOlsonheasef`oHthatssumariginaloint,ndTfalHcausealltreAumberaquestionsne:or!emdecepQies5sm@nesbifferencTouriluroeitexact1 defini8‘premiss’oofisuza8esaideason.

8w?"1??8jupfyESienow`8many+ppa؄yllogismHepend,osophichNJrefutamayd.ylO>eanotlhichearsTvdu@s!,bP,ugh2,lohpropriathing!-.he؊0t hveeopl͎oraaccordLnat:w funcmrfmKN@dialepc:$aaeonclusbeʃ冬Ȅmnswr.ӐGH (r胠,ve:20radictorysis,omakHl`@eÄȣ Ssntang ciwewit:Bgؠ70ҝ427772TAubySaliȇ8in80҆>siderB8ÒaudlreedΨДHaskȭ <Aould[wk =,ajiccthrB񇸓pswҥap:#s gQk%.fPurQ2ќKmxpadـ1߀ supsity.g.laPxKYlPuagsop.Ɉbou*of^aԃir+xÏϞlbyum9.numbYqsآelevolIaenuneoɫԱÓOvre#\BńWfowrom (wXmpoble)treatwoqɻogalaw5pre,??ubtuccessattrih-#last-_Ui0p:XverQp rcPп:by:insteX0wtunis4resp(i n y򖨆1*Rmt“77fickfhsumpݻ2riginXY`]viol‘9o reckon1$’.hH haǡǕ^>y߈),:ҀO0esaid///////*A phicHQaab0Xqvyä$Bway.ƈunl'Ϟmbigu{ڋAtermralPli8sm۟~eg͙2aK2neЊWrhיϊɇnsar:h@dothȀ2a(;珱ecHptboX:v rPo,nd thatnlyromhisarticularan.

9w?"1??8justifyETheumberfnsideratiPhichependeefutfose0ored,euotory9grasputnowledgpfveryngis.ԋX,ow,@provincanypecialtudy:orossibsciexsBinfinitI,0Bbviousdem0tumay熀o.ow/trues@llAfalsewhenq-ysomejJowpk"maint sp`dictojth;.g.؁hse! IdiagoncommensuҍXsqu,pyhimg8 e.ccord(ly,1exhalhhav€Bzic//s9x\upCiplЅruge a̋pclus*Rfolles@rsтmehinHomdʖ.Ɔ@3tx3atʇlikewibeloa/-+a02aof,Ӂ]ic(.y ‘׆0’,Ɂ8i.lear h ѣiXbX~Onalecەneam-plasڜh aL l1faty`qsPgard׫-Ql_7ask_\ti؞2am1ҁmap`beqrealѪwԆashQit: ssFiaP߈cH,firȑ矔unhg`d8xngpoܖccepBjubj@Jb_Ocur"݂ka_nŃU_\aiveseђ;tw8ԂOOpstitAon.׆IͅwhichsuH:(,ow'xiqlu;zҋ8ま3m ?m؃q-M,2bod peoPcertahmp#(iەHqoqui@xPmakmئaree8ydc)SIan(sτ۠ab>ǨȀ9rougIOOJ />ԥٌi.e../)קsuit n<

10&G"1GG@jufyMILruPntweargumPsomXdraw ʨ(ay\!ϔd(cag@!exprZA*8[e absursuppN͛#yamp-failu1oq}H ocȋienJado(1g n؞uPaueA enxUrɁ}Ht?xt2gهg*ooo.τS蜨G׉>wheneveranseshexpressionnsam(ensehichanswereradImindenerantet.fowy (i.e.otquest@(a耙persȀd),dealingi؅h'moreЁeanp,ouppoitqhaveGng-as.g.mayZt ‘Be’Oneqys,yetKs&utsis\akhPrgumentpoffechAll`h-wisiscudirXr9againsg`!oughtf׍ed?,򈨑ZndmՓ׃u

<lor="#000">IooYtoges#Tefu9t]HProof: 򁏡Љ,+J/#weRPb `׃gfd˒9pQ+txtradictoraiAccordly 0ass!D,G)(/added)!timY҃bPSw.Ʉ։zpamHǃil9o,;uGcpgivdoiPXovÂZH8r0bfigthrᛩayc/xXy?faili8‘HruyPtur((虸gedmaAcalwwAh?@ nXnksѿXleabMgydiff`sen8fromSwvH)Qtw8(ŌڇNh!5For@OOOOOOOIM8r7剹b۳.uxX8sup8ZhaH㭘Qq׈׈׀!ρowqko𯰁Inexcep@uggbP-}hjCϣϭ)ā- followxI,zNo”n oneense,ut “Yes”nnother?’f,hen,ywereosXattasotossibleKy+Pd9ɂrguH,

yhowrclaim‹lctu8(rawdincIsay,Byspea@gusilPIea΁0a,re2firplacbhd (fPstimeeueȃrȀse1mbiguitXfmcanψ}ao@nkL):secoЅ,؋elswididicbe?2Ymake(nifӔ(Aohoӏɐns(r!!knowKZ "iAJ8Ȝ@Pa8ghe"Huzuy?yA؁fourqx wos?bservO tЍZY .x"Ic!ledgB1rariȪrr9YO)Р+un҃Th c"unawdiffnbetwialic f`+!c|sks*ʅear mselm/ɨ>MoreoBaAYesahNoa쉸ss!𚹨 ,3fF(holdZnxamin&0Iran0ȐȘviewܔᘖ[opreter.ȁ1q&i\regardcommpriplithirlجʠt@Pulmat؅h%ona8ap`t.Ω0)HioHr reaso: (1)uRMpn,H@bjС̜wόroptho`8ougclrue:bmiscausX(2)記֮1o؂Sl9inquiryWUDQge`Ђ݅fagragerfigur̅(ulgiЭQ߷#P)-mHYn-x+mayo0th-e.g(icr8*ۡa gcirŒ unu.ŠBry`sO7Tiׂпue!tillwbe1doА.Ӻ*:aboL*?ٶd݄ϚˍuwOOKۃT itx' -,;deceptivЇ plays(ulQЄx!aakefHtypfaps kiہꓰhYOs/nsputTaeYphbɜolv؈`p(cosXspryĬlÂڤȅgeerThose,hen,hoohisnrderohtheereictory`generallyonsixedbetentiousnduarrelsomeersileoseitaeputa nthviewmakingoneSsoptical.oartf兠iasaid,’Pd9t- fromɇ(app`ntpsdom`Љshy0itde@:…soemploPargumpbuto@motives#hll!lRאIrespect;ar,qmsoarqi8 auD-al:ǏǏÌxcertappearance)oreality.Ԁh stx

Ty؆typpXg >beloPǏ@tud:AoXeffpRxdiffɀeeinti9ቩesxQIٚ"a8 3Jc(ersize="1xbww12&G"1GG//>S(=2p𶑌`AsꜰwiMsmmittҗlacɀщarguminkadox-SeyH5’rome-firpƂbhbo(`ai(10qu9că.ƅa؂@ϑfȂ(`0聱/(gooapur@peo@˧clؗm9)lktrgUǀāHn '#beJ8(Y&` agȌ3(Ђa8quل%AiiȐh1sa nwkcbundaopportuyzmohrѭXoe, repli‘YesXiNo,lea򈐦xوXwepoffSattack.owadayȝ@aq肠ܙ ul1meX,1merlyrej×opW IWorig?IPoelarupelnj̊}r!uld ros_wa(9V؞YishzinҲpcpinthdoh⌰oooooiAspelpXroؘgp5׺*ъQkisupYd]bcȟdbo2iH{`Ksai.yAɒyaic ,oo肠seschoo hiloH youlongnQp赋ioctr)؅Olroi3yEaڃX.뚿8"oÙllvario@`mxћ`ts.ԓ*lutionecommendedsppropriateere,oo,s@ointutha)earadoxoesotomeb)becausefZarguHt:уhthwqaopponlwayseallyants.

Moreover,eromen’hish`andirrofessopinions.oeopleЇ:sang(!eyyK1:willookst,;earBbo􌐁xse.g.ߍaanPdie`braHr)nlivePluhsttd(onourabric;B%َsite.ccord ly`2whokml`tat:Q?<ɍ+i؁8??tXadmit$okee@iddenᕀ:搸eicaareouroduc;҉lp Pary-oed>Tid!rangPmon-plaYJ037raa8 G3DDc(er=size="1xbϞ13&G"1GG>P%%_eekeЪme\ on-plaru.o蠠!babpȑvldkЃQ@Ёȓobjecz@all`gudfollow@d:f q񭁕Ќpm ipdehb#douåhalfʑ %: 肇`xi@//)oA0if staWqagapu 0sф=ereimׄυlsoZesiȌ $asanisnXRWcoI5:Ol߁߁ڀ177A}1ccuIH(1)ArelYsnoalygenera,utrelsohemselveselative,ndrenderednonon ameHings.g.oncisgforomeedesi80TofoublSi.e.alf:˅deal0 (2)ithyermshich,oughAyeot6La`ll,etheiHubstanchviz.Rs9򂳊9:tat affecrwhXndic(؅ellsdefinibp؁s-.hul‘odd’)aynumbertaPaiddle0:han 򎀆ځD--a-ˁ.x@nubnessaycavitylsd32ԃ2Ke-1Z

Peop*imappearproduc*ysulorply$ibecaudoahque0whxexssXӇ,ꅘyxf,hyea`nyـXiъ2k,jiHt;hrawlustraway.tiAte8!asmuworx玨o>wOHa8 3!⎄cer}size="1xb14&G"1GGǑǂ>WesaidkЗAsolecism.9It9poЧYbopXcommQBoJA`(doُ< ͍uphsrotagorXX3aHmen(wrath@)pelexhelHˇmascue8cchim1xwhXtructሁ(oulnen),ͮΒ(doׇٶ1pzrЃoo߃ߗ,clpr 8cЉآ/jarH#؋Las؉1gu}pd jhqسHu__Almo)DePdpnxJtode)*ocxʎhinfx2dneȓqdXf1yobjau.Ɓ hy)tos)Xgnifi1Ila)+OIpPܧ0򎰄,ftaߑ薃mer:.g.aWIRis?CiopQ;ylogJori.ow%?-QL+ҁsxn.χ*?=jbegr@ed,$MfZiÞphPʭ+likewi subtXʇa@.Ԍ)acy9baυ΋cmasevera W:JWrtiiWTmsņPlnately;bd;8i0>b2:qibewsǓ (KopiskYz,5ZI\2sawnouycc_Z:o-10 c򮚿Rr/@donnoقnqph؄3,x8nSschoр;ϰȃ闐z3ppp4aqRw0skinq3Oq+kbedZKnэyQdᢠwiXa9sobetwnstrusinaixA8,Ӽeresembl0xertaP񌣻ǐaaxp1Iunngs.or, justshereeomeponaterialolecism,PWVverbal:or ‘man’sothtp)expressindlȁ:word(: white.

Itclear,n1atڇmetryonstructurrgumeou f1esaidnf0tsThesea8typestiouss@HAsubdivizthos/medsJdpingm.‡itknoittleiffnce鈓put}ueHbrrange0certaP0ner view4ceal酸sycahdhcs.ollowncw9havhy`JXdiscuss`firsta8 '3$$cersize="1xb15&G"1GGgg>Wrefuta,nesXqsength-9Ѐiiculoeepe@xng҂򊈌;+o8cuelea@ruljbesbeshoulmployeO XѢh,speed;bwpeopYlef ؗRyookheadsxMo Xsnp,'agiybody{sb舐t@himself.ňro1oRpwmwisolayul4oltog`sham@QȐs lXnly,hmindأфluڂWP9ڑJsPouЕSno!󃁑0Aˑyguarti(eg9linɀrѐ=.nealdescribяϧ؀usl#3rpدOobj`Dpvo@det;ʁsdeceiveggcYuATwh o簐Hsupɀhelpnͦ䖨GAnegvBy8ghYiroithnswQ@n(`׃b/,ioprejudiNkobJ+Zw,hractory.an ȹRparular)c[ividu0Sпi ᄑyoumof0BunXrs@, qxكPisMvN!ڱb]iтxappea[aeX"R8mbssH7Y8 Y韚sʫ$nermcA' ,i airiЅlau= ρɎiap`1aۂobtpiaAP Xn+~sidhЀAiHŸ.if@e cXNd‘AҔbPfa@j¡kSꁶҁdis2?;Vnum8ipliIy(g(ȀONgreB m!xƗcmpell PchoKw2i0* kiUppla:ir}ihclbmXفsookig)h!rel̜+bsolutCwoRbet@'''''''"Aro`+ *Cos sopx@unfa@trickJoⳀ4instea1t鋻fin8WQtqaXcluI,shoughheyadrovedat ‘Thereforeo-and-sosotrue’

Italaxphi`calPick,henparadoxpselaidown,irso9posephtartmeiewhgenerallyccepted,ncm[!answhrh|thinkbout<ᕀze="1xbcolor="#000">16&G"1GG@AifyMW)ȏa4 uPe8nn ious :ex1p[G9solu\;,requ@tervhbQckGϊȊj2)ϊϊϊʴpSx0aȋosptwof.Ƙl1~Zoa)deДmexsIyڌ)⯿seҴً`8(Xmhxy`embladiffoccwengQpIsseaK{`fulꠅYsonearc;Xicommi:a柀acy񡒟els,doy kn jf)"mselxHphirdlastly1fur"ibukree,ebwellhЇ0xryچxi1* :atartyorgumentshouldin(aultithhem,feannote(itelyointutAireakness,reatesuspicion,akingteemsoughwerePruofjmatter0m(inexperienc`hathimZem.

Ans rspylear@0owImeetwisxourreviouccouwr]s8cwhfallacicame,alsordixnctЂdequMform20hoxin9gu.‰`s`@take΂!p’sr nqsolvesCh80b(blquickxwhibesubjecteo:Ɂ@wenow,IoftdoAaffbntext.oreover,pʆr@pe`enc`bPrang,\toorsuppos9aunpraXsepevaquĆ˂mo.Ӏ@tim0Ihappe4diagrams; ЃxanalysɃ@igurscrag`:bynefuta,ŌkZoncdedllBaosspl8axa8 3Qcersize="1xb??17&G"1GG>FirhALjX_ohoooȖbgeneralЪ(yrad1A¢@haU={W''#rd".Ɣ aruhznh`@sӂ@ʕaar*e䊿Iynxt(hZscas(oarXm0xpel :9Iihfnnambradiriv8fromertiewyXn( Araw72ْmphiboA!ity:e`roof.Ԇonmotrfurwplȧ Xaday@or8ofulfqQCOd answei‘YesqhNo`:IلN m؂!8ich'rscom party”g…3׌zPaulxaosi*ٯ(Qgshxmean!pquky(ou2p??=.

InyUg؉Rsup11u˩iswr[/w(qossibl{݃pescapѯ?da8ns`vi{j7nec@e ahrёc-Iedc3medyDopHIxqevailкҨ!يCoriscthcЄuntPscusnmusical.uthisilloto,oroay ‘Coriscussn’,r),nds(8(useehmexpression:+ـ0bothffirmingdenybtnce.iperhapheyxmeanF.1Well,riQimpleQisHmerase:herzdiffx?f,oweverHoscribooneso\tit0' whì(radhfixقІ["commitsbsurdity:lattȂnooappl@b煩thgrichit؋ake7.

Ahu,HfჸnҖXinguishsensoHxmphibolyz(lear1haeennfuted!qπȗ\rgumen؃rYmgran CeviМȁ2queythodraw c:h`0axfhimsel(9rat Dookxoughihad#@.ɜXftppseیWohesituchobecapjrowfssumYpeXiwhiȀwȏr璪oposȖق D=too)uppaatdepends.

IfrdebarّB eю!{Ȏiarg _эQerw9pac(g8aesaidinc:betwdifferkiɖXlacyccasЀP@I\0dtansw4simp)r)draw)(7:acؗ"d8xiPtee.g.t}Wp:0aelliptly-32ߟ4tƆexa@pIs+beloɄxAiTtHf?@eAXlikewioBHBobserve;aBnimgdom,oesyaxT OH.ك2 ނ ́႟ca+,򊐂ys@ׂӫip2.Ɋevidڬ Xswar؞Ò[ʀӍ#???????:Wiwј{"t!:iÜttru󀕞iRityreaguix-2askxKmʏ@lnTnumb󌜶9hìM}mfgaiJop1iqoBtr)le®,up3iayByoueyዑnoblish高S`@treg1omviewzysmoAeoXnwhPؑ!admwtysehooH:ɂlytЫЏopinɾid (ǑviJul1#drubimmo`l)@ccorp(1)u 'sepE$ usume-maxim|yZH9sbPtdՂвZ)ɳibdoc莈hiagonquIcom@sur`pits@de:jheo!(2)YXAthnsubjec0{x8as@ohang3mingydetedǍǍa|"iAb1oqplayck op<߂߂߇Y.È__jre(x ma,iruWWWWWWWSM򐤇 se`1qu؄87XXPaݢb8dCdosoUambarrB-ZeffPJxa8a>18

20&G"1GG@justifyMItievidhsoowd0lvosensdepup diviconzfords:orfrexpresmeasomethingHffPwhpd(ed,s@pߒ߆akWҀraryay.lluOْolloww$h‘WXXe)ben@thQyouawmwp?`DidCeGYOTfallacyciPnlem)pamphiboque(,reHys#n.ƉِQI}'"$aubl_(?s),lHE`pronounccc؅b0"ero0ЀJaP/). (HwritindeӁȄҪ0jوlerˌ­—Kpeophnowadaymark ĉHw) iQZpokaame.)a@wP:rs:it ˈ%sayq`oǫOHL2OOOJTwhn,큀$R;pI--a-- 0Wmyyesi[p`1a;4-1-my-4I+qarguEEuthydevnkSiciRtrirPniraeu:ragaiC1oodwhЙobrad"pNo.TBǀ yYai:g]wipۂAHngsledg؂A`lear nRyYes͐, ,!l`Ć,9ut,,bojڂ-to-5>@X-GltXgyIȈhru@4am8borÉ'ga}No;gXM2pff@{y-ine-T-tXr[)Yn??ntouldoca9)s76ٷharp2havp8o҄_\:0:uX-le--; rely,Tdoi肌ohiSߕljla琩awell.o{yf}grantranyc4it8do)foll'be'"Iy2hK;󕢰׉`ډъ;䆇Ad: perlyPH/pp$olure*Bxa`casX2inye`putt2(quepons:v $ȁonIՁ1.

21&G"1GG@ju(fyMAc1u giv risnoaciousrguments,ithersrittenrspokenxcepterhapomeewhatighteadep;.g. ollowingrgj. ‘Isuatalueisouse?’Yes.\P@xegatiofׂButsaid{_X:refore eHowneldXlvi0hclear:r*wordoesoHeansaw ncutAndravccI

22&G"1GG@justifyMItVxsoXm(et(ofallacidepeȏ!idXicalpressfangahсn,eeweinoss#einddؐ s.Ǝԅasay,`d,aska3ermXbubstancebeloᓈttrib`qilo"Yw1Z~48hich9CategoryRelryQuit0usuy)utoۃ@σPcaits/n̠:iibodoB h`8҇htimNot,e@surel/,aspect Agai+anyoIavP@act/-T1“Yput”burnstruckysen[obj`jkr=o[a%prunwIYNaHqG@:ׂGA'abǕ;D_[wWySup脰e8*@ca`qf9nY/oGwsljϖiP Hqyb@s[im70e ()0que0`requi9welx+ dalistenP5alreadyezh_Z?i0;ځdOx1LhHzt4Cϲadyiselfin蒱eanbz:8qDGIappx1g.Ԕh؃"ambigu8Àdbou?atyroysopneg@и

L2boIpWW`.ɪski@ahlowc

<lor="#000">LikesXylsllhgumhsfBfollowkind:爫strQa0reyOߍFhBoonye.omeeoolpjcase 94mnjxel1byayd.ϞsCefutviewZ,=receHd A瑹^voteCB,aPotrom͞`g,cedemolisR azawayHposiZzdmitt$xsib@hrE;Dweeanځhig0gXArp:pńs.u w sai0bb, Kp`onsip ipoluA)Ɏ(,.Ҭ rbaenu 0supࠉi9:ojf0ЂG6happe@ംBs|=truGbeSo-(-諉artZـj]ʘxpreaoficQsop8вsPf

23&G"1GG@ifyM#aenerruln0wrgupelanguagaolualways`llow{opposipeoixfZTurns:.g.YpXbin$?nsisІ9;ꀕԁ n.gaipcuc!򃟊ravNjGD`guۙ`18bys׌@erm;youIrself:?hnim ,sp)qviousiiȧݞЁhowsenQl:פpndCde(фMsoph$vZ..ikewialPPambolyneHex"k.ICould爐Kot?INh;⮩j:Aaف ,#i`t .Doyknب<(learnzdiscrya Csly?R5JlWlect(ȄAAɄCt@d perhapH2y walkrqtim72exles777777747777G773AccrKNameeȡHZ@Fi`.deIAЦ)ttriPhz1scj0Ɂrcelook,5ąq

Siveqseefutasyemoliszriginalroposi"asked:懲ey8yHatsossiblonowndotމ:,nly $respect:ccordHly,he"Pon’t@ocom owardsm,utCorsicus,casser!׃O߈bj߅߀.e2aalreadymar prrxofrgumentxdepe(uppoiou8bjډ(Honellstyifadop"rincipPregȍowy·ʎ@la㊘aPte.g.upyXifa0فlsooursptru(yetth[Eds9o`.ÆÕщprevrom9IaumbHflaws;cexn@ryulctitut這aJPshaxXQclusbe`vIÉ w`LZeno؈E*moimE.oa!bt8e0by݂8doct`‡H ,ؘmikeneYңousAtimP[n߇ߩ?w@aalonÞonBlB.f)(2yĊ_Ba (ꄓZ2#x󖙔b.Ќxinde=ssuggpmȗz9ppx: pr‡񆚄wouldgeКgr 8qXisXQfBtroacfiguTǓ5Z{whik@qlizٟ8cal4wx…gBAY//򊖋׋֥ϙ+.

AikӅ냀Xxwh(}8YGC2:Ҧsm 4J䬝yaseЉs8āﮗ\ٞ؃cgrouOK™X($mYwwwwwwwrSIpeop@o

25&G"1GG@ju0fyMThargumpsichup芜Phv ulabQ1כspecplaceRmannerZon,j!gP Pvˡsiderlub itradictor(8nЎҞRcؤ4y`hȃȂz.ƇQimACrixyoȀsaffirmpg{beloy҈o؃,owX8:ȍaxfrom7YϯǂǂǂƇ I'.ӇePF @77҈snofut.ԃ eatuXqhh examiaJnmisq.2IAlxޣfollowk‰ꆼ:Iٝ-ٓ"?Nouyouy,su,spiLikewilso,³rwiȁC;₈mɅFomzkebreaksڭx?C(b`bedxaanbOnPc9bˊ.ᇟkaP?τ{hP,t-8J.neȂQYÚ%0пsVchstancȮGBbou9Ybuwhwear)Ɏj#ɑ,ronhg:Ўy⏓diaoughɥ˃)dimizXrrdprom0𓇄qGDsay͕fȲtru`P\trouXJqueqecauAeas,hipDtwonexwordYϓrenHed-ʁ@񀜆ڷz`4ɇǍMQו߱R.e.Ǽ% / pla.Ƅa'''"d`8up@Ҫ0healq\aoo}YeX@#oldo؇i𶐑7:;E Ɂi71polialPw߅yمa`|ly!3xrPӔꔟ𬋑D㔧܃Woarticularan,reingoodoandetot3here. ‘IshathichXerudentouldwishYvil?’Yes.\Butg@rif, :Qreforesрistake;isam1!sayyTYOHg`.ikeelso2argumၴefn.ƅcaSlcquirBsف):Pes,,u`bۑ :omeA.,ȅɅ?=Ɇ/xeustpeferabl+unɔ slaclyY߀܁ly?דׂoHkdeath)GŅ0H*eashhave聸ownoever`cision:`contrengx0personalpin,enxa揰eahval@inaw resuljbo`#ʎˇonednvourmؚBs+Mmertouei piredҎ1fulQyPhasufPeX@i0*becauтpȖ{lȀт TWoughɂ(luyeryelett`܅XʋȒ], #a(z4y:ȜbFquestaaӁmDZy]rgsupports:z7??:Qߵnner="bsolutely\Ed5hpeakSm;SaK/,ecessiQm|8y;GǴh[neވSa__fwspoY{victo goˢ&1< &‚فs/.Byt.

26&G"1GG@ifyMRefuta鈜depeHtdefQ}풣ccordD(ketchxabov0yy@[onclu wiitstrads ڒdshinvol

28&G"1GG@j(ifyMAlsoabring23irncluꀸseyou@cour8 self.Ԁmonhichcfollxiwohd.Ɣx_Xeixr"Aeihs#articular-X(e.g.) ‘animal聎man-sooj.laXmafal th €P''.rl[ceedyՖTermsvolxBE؂xZABi،|B߀؄Ylathč' XMelQsseecayjcomЀyaHnp_1ЌEheavbeX.¢yso;nvi@r''''''o'9''''G''Iaany_Xwɡ1addiQ,ookkefksubtracjbsurH̍l:*"0 nswer3rou@7$b{IVB ,8?ނزx/purBaN ll30GToeemseЉE񛸝ddraw8di(nCbetwemQЌtر3a텘Qs`l"{ѝaݒW1affirmrExngn0~8ySkmbiguoi0tri eplo`a tJbo:ePˇ_!mp&sap(Xno`despᅩfP;ITʃZˇ[@idoubtoo.ן1󟣋fja!ubjecțZKTQ#Hnc؆!bcqmi@:jȆwM Mumba'D8p ?yi@acgaiky?trzFbewa is.h(e.g.) ůSupXgood:Bil,ouplPiώab0pelloO#truct[GGDm2likewiȀԆA(eamc er){x+񆩎bnl.li0crykɂsel(@diff8fromelinasmul%sGEyxdrf/*‘’Ӣ

N eseefutationsainrovinceYeroluS0well:hr ‘’x@qhavexinnpean,`resultaffirmz;eni8iIdo@notccuXexcepterby:XsAJw n.u8Rcleare"p(aque@YumbHpobhansw rpedrQattri`nlysubjecbsurditySoas a8 G3DDc0er=size="1xbϑ31&G"1GG>Wiregarowhorawjrepezi zwqygr9predicrelhЈms+anXۄPAtracXH.g.Ø@doubleYXgnif`قparphrahalf9mP (ou:a@iguX it.Ɠ t@minuXnҙIۈdo,generiׁۜyn;bQqupp!ɋɘsaX`T߬QtY,ρPցH*.ԁbwoX perhapscyevȎ?`llY&y1h ÂbОye6:binN `knowledg/*pec!h胈(iopl)J‚Lk@1ga.Ɇсڍiy ghXndefine@youhould|qjnכhconc+M0?)PnubPse{bPye虡whdde(1upHڊtڡzdiff0i;YfpibZenhpplɿ<aq'%XP nnextς sed X.ak†ce2kaIy.͞overexssI"|oӎ)Zalsehood1nmsȍ( 8)longRo:(ҿ1+Ԉ~;R sy<ӂӕȃ.?>

<lor="#000">ThuargumHakiVlecismۮXso`b@zy4ᶘs`mee mcl9fromK>LJa8 3Zcersize="1xb33&G"1GG??>Wؼyal`obserpq(ʌaѩ* easih@ee`"soHЀhastr҂bڼ(mqdifficulPtg ftB8_worw сldepe upopoint;*po!ʈł`cTidHLߓ rlsea1hnrk1erm X{.ccorIlPfHaciel/ambiguit˄@)er }pill@tۂm tt (uoۆȟD;.gTgcarow8Ƀ3𶚌1CЄboT#yardmcwyNeerCbed;b3I Noreed;J`murؐ(beggerch sGoodn-Kaob-02ajor;well)eludmoexpe(Kympt ZҠ+f 耺iʘRa*PBend ‘One’sheamenllirpplicationsrifferent;xsothink0at ‘Beingandmean&;hilers0lv9ergumfeno*Paridesyssert resedumbersenses),ikewislsPsegardsacixAcc؄eachaypes,K̆-siHbesiaoe1mo(iculЄhgraspIclXylongwheitia`futnon,)equpyyca.

Ancisi(onbproducgreatesterplexity:j@sUithhar0tng.ow熰wofold,ccuxsd,spec2|ۅHposi{askoemolish ciou??ymannޗZRunded.ԃ0epsyllogicRj@!keetart-s0c amoifromemi`graccept(ossibH}a clusy2!ǂw/le.ƑsM؎cradictor2chbou8mak٨[YQmacterSalway@w&j01XntBrCaPi,֜iGedۑoee ѝ؉ǁpRkitτ,iz.Ƅpui ǀfoAfsedm< oi `S]@vangPj7›҂؃loI3should..ȋPfԁm}g,u75huncxain.fGGA}0 ljHfirqCkizм ~(er0+ʁolu"depenؑ h draw!non;Lb{hewcl@Є]upjGR3ye(o(reveP} ˳6SφPWRq@br-

a:i ^Ǔǫsy,upXumshquirhbxte#౸ȁTewɕ;Houxnrlef)bzerb8Subjec@r)ˮ`z9faPu(jwellGSBs٦smitQane釭$noea00htspisY)h(tpxabQXR]ڑxʀۇJÓsiJa?agɝA)imodݲneؑcslikew{marsh’לdOesiyIǀswρ``longpexamiXKiovАa8 '3$$cers="1xb34&G"1GGgg>Aj umber0sourcPfallacies ariseniscussion,ndowereoythaturpponentsommittingallacy makeimtteraradoxes;oreover,yeofmapialsolescism9broughtboutquestxwaorang0e/(axoY:XservedYpgumsthkindconcernYqanswerer’sbothageneralIicular @vÍIs-Ʉxngsetf gouffice.temainrecAriginalroposH bralowieords@t.

O脸gramms,Q8fa0tyAreaso‘x(ppbeAxrommostlccept(pisse Xș.ore0nt@askkYfn (d ec)2examJ(peiraxc)nasmuch,eiannex8iHccounecrpPtry (\,onفhbX8duc1_Nb9lso Xknowledge, [ptt7isaidЂbeۄˇjviewRensut8upڂ`ԅsh)defea9Ȃsamarme 1 s(l(oH.ԂS惐haexplHed;ᗑo(whyocrЛ)ɓ~ڊIs fЈkdH.ׄtmade,͋pr/AcedeumbpX0whi \b ihяpmplishe\:sc芀cbeesupЇb::ƕgK>roXm_^uagAv$er/*a9AIPbelokinqui к|ddiς8e Subj0Faci1)ƇdyAveTɲ. h(zqu(eAj.¢0hm(m`ahappp8arTaLsXzvio`lYughdqadvad(

Tiwebpublish:2IeBooks@Adelew:brX)GGG@ԋ0Uni ȩHfibraryǂDžgSouAا8ia 5005w'ak/> NMody>INDXTAGX 00IDXTINDX00nȀIDXTTopFLISAFCIS7o